OUR VISION
Transformational Mitigation, LLC is a leading provider of mitigation and sentencing advocacy for state and federal criminal defense cases across the nation, with particular focus in Maine.
Our team is dedicated to advocating for criminal justice reform and firmly believes that effective mitigation is essential in ensuring fairness and balance within the legal system.
With a wealth of experience working with individuals from diverse backgrounds, we are committed to helping our clients achieve lenient and/or alternative legal outcomes and set them on a path towards a brighter future.Our team's expertise in social work, restorative justice practices, and navigating the complexities of the criminal justice system enables us to deliver our services through best practices that our clients can rely on.
​
We work closely with our clients' attorneys to develop a strategic approach that maximizes the chances of a favorable outcome. Our comprehensive mitigation reports serve as a powerful advocacy tool, aiding with plea negotiations, trial preparation, sentencing hearings, and post-conviction review.
Our track record of securing below-guideline sentences speaks volumes about our commitment to achieving the best results for our clients.
​
Certified through the National Legal Aid & Defender Association (NLADA) and the National Alliance of Sentencing Advocates & Mitigation Specialists (NASAMS), we adhere to the highest standards of professionalism and expertise in our field.
We are thrilled to offer mitigation for clients receiving services through the Maine Commission on Public Defense Services (MCPDS) and are always ready to take on new cases.
Our Approach
We offer an initial consultation with the attorney, client, or family to discuss the case needs and how our mitigation services can best assist in achieving a successful outcome.
Through interviews and direct work with the client and their support system we aim to uncover sensitive, yet crucial information and explain its significance within the client's overall circumstances and life journey.
Proficiency in humanizing our clients through an empathetic narrative supported by collateral testimony, visual media, expert assessments, and scholarly research is an invaluable tool at the attorney’s disposal that can move the needle in even the most complex of cases.
Our training and experience navigating sentencing goals allow us to engage in a collaborative process with our clients' attorney every step of the way.
Utilizing a team of mitigation specialists with complementary backgrounds and skills as a means of assuring quality outcomes. Empowering each individual to focus on the aligning narrative with a tailored approach, without overlooking any of the necessary details. This collaborative problem solving method sets us apart.
With a focus on compassion and respect, our non judgemental approach builds rapport and trust in the client relationship.
Encouraging and guiding our clients on a positive trajectory and providing emotional support through this transformational process.
A holistic approach provides support to the client as well as their support network. Case management is a social work specialty, and our ability to support, guide, and coordinate care through a trauma-informed approach closes the loop on any concerns that arise for the client and their support system. By positively impacting the client’s social environment it will in turn strengthen their community support.
Our Services
Comprehensive Mitigation Memorandum
Character Reference
Letter of Support Assistance
We employ our specialized letter writing guide to help collateral contacts develop meaningful and powerful letters to be submitted to the court. These are letters from the heart and authenticity is the most
important factor. Our services include interviews with letter writers to help them find the most powerful subjects to focus on in each letter.
Client Letter of Remorse & Responsibility
The paradigm we employ in our mitigation process is one where we take our client on a journey of enlightenment, self reflection, and understanding. We work with each client to connect the dots as to how their past led them to the present moment. It is a process of developing insight and accountability.
We hold space for our client to feel their feelings; often of shame and regret. Ultimately our paradigm is one of deep inner transformation. A client’s letter of remorse is authentically reflective of this deeply emotional journey. It is critically meaningful to the judge for the purpose of sentencing, parole, or clemency.
Mitigation Video
We have a production team with proven ability to share the compelling and emotional story we uncover and develop through a short film to be used during sentencing or plea negotiation.
*Length varies based upon the case and attorney input.
Alternative Sentence Proposal
Whether your client is awaiting sentencing or is currently incarcerated and seeking compassionate release or parole, we can design a comprehensive plan of rehabilitation and re-entry. Customized plans include mental health treatment (if appropriate) and/or a personalized community service opportunity building on our client’s strengths, past service work, AND that has a direct anecdotal relationship to the offense itself. The plan will show that the client is learning from their greatest wrongdoing and is trying to
use this knowledge to benefit others. If your client is in need of continued services, treatment, and monitoring we can connect them with the most appropriate resources available to meet their ongoing needs.
Liaison & Emotional Support to Incarcerated Clients
If your client is currently incarcerated we are able to work with them on a weekly or bi-monthly basis to support the transformative work that puts them on a positive trajectory ahead of sentencing. Through journaling and motivational sessions we work with your client through a trauma-informed lens to connect the dots in their life leading up to the present moment. Gaining the insight to take full responsibility for their actions and feel remorse for their wrongdoing. From there we can do deep healing work of their trauma so that they can be on a healthy and productive path.
Process
Consultation
We offer a free consultation with each of our clients and their attorney. This ensures we are the right fit for the needs of the case.
Customized Service
We create an individualized plan for each case we take on. The services we recommend aim to present a compelling humanization of the client and an explanation of their offense that evokes empathy and affirms their humanity.
Collaboration
We believe the best outcomes result from working together. This includes all involved parties; our mitigation team, the client, attorney, collateral contacts, etc.
Our Team
Ashley Oettinger
Mitigation Specialist
Licensed Social Worker
Currently calling Kennebunkport, Maine home, Ashley is a former resident of the Hudson Valley in New York. Ashley is a seasoned Mitigation Specialist with a background in Social Work, earning her Masters in Social Work (MSW) from Hunter College School of Social Work in the city of New York. Specializing in child trauma through the National Childhood Traumatic Stress Network (NCTSN) curriculum. Ashley is certified in mitigation through the National Legal Aid & Defender Association (NLADA) and the National Alliance of Sentencing Advocates & Mitigation Specialists (NASAMS) with a registered social work license in multiple states.
With 20 years of experience in the human services field, Ashley has navigated working with youth in residential placement and foster care, community crisis hotline response, and in a state correctional facility as a social worker. It was this hands-on experience that sparked her passion for mitigation work. Naturally empathetic and driven to help others, Ashley is a fierce advocate for justice. She remains hopeful for a criminal justice system that focuses on healing and transformation, rather than punishment and retribution. Ashley brings a unique blend of expertise, compassion, and determination to her work.
Currently calling Kennebunkport, Maine home and formerly of the Hudson Valley in New York.
Ariel Troy
Mitigation Specialist
Ariel is passionate about public defense, mitigation, and investigation— as well as transformative and abolitionist visions of justice. As an Investigator Team Leader at Brooklyn Defender Services in New York, Ariel mentored and managed a team of six investigators in addition to working on over 550 cases. She has extensive field and interviewing experience on all types of cases. Ariel earned a Master’s in Criminology and Criminal Justice at University of Oxford. She volunteered with Circles U.K., participating in circles of accountability to help reintegrate convicted sex offenders into society. Ariel is a certified crisis counselor with the Crime Victim Treatment Center, where she provided support and advocacy for victims of sexual assault and domestic violence in emergency rooms in New York City. Additionally, Ariel has been an investigative intern at the Public Defender Service in D.C. and ArchCity Defenders in St. Louis.
Ariel graduated from Washington University in St. Louis with a degree in Conflict Resolution and earned a Masters in Criminology and Criminal Justice at University of Oxford in the UK.
The entire team of professionals which includes Antoinette, (the other) Ashley, and Brianna, assist with letters of support, utilizing motivational interviewing techniques, and offering empathetic support to the friends and family of our clients. We recognize the significance of a collaborative team approach, and each member of our diverse team brings a unique perspective and expertise. We are dedicated to making a tangible impact for our clients and their loved ones.
State of Maine v. "TB"
29-year-old client facing charges including VOP and aggravated trafficking. With mitigation, the attorney was able to leverage the Kennebec CARA program.
"Getting the CARA program is definitely better than I ever hoped for. I really never imagined a scenario where I wouldn’t be in jail or treatment for quite a while. The program is supposed to help transition me back to freedom with housing and other support which is a big relief.
I appreciate all the work you put into making that happen. I’ve never had a person to talk about the events and issues that have led me here and you were always willing to listen, thank you. I believe I will make the most out of this opportunity and hopefully improve the relationship with my family and others. You not only gave me the opportunity but also began that process. When I complete the program, I will make sure to let you know how I am doing.
Thank you for everything." -"TB"
Commonwealth of PA v. "JB"
An adolescent client, "JB", was facing both youth & adult charges in connection to multiple robberies and assault. Their attorney was able to have all charges dropped. With help from their extended family & mitigation recommendations "JB" was able to relocate with family outside of the U.S. on a student visa.
"I cannot thank you all enough for your work for our family. You really and truly gave this kid a second chance and an opportunity for a new life! I hope you remember on the hard days just what a difference you are making in this world!!" -"JB" Aunt
State of Maine v. "JE"
43-year-old client facing multiple burglary charges. A mitigation memorandum was provided for an open plea sentencing requesting CODC. The client was sentenced to 8 years all but 10 months suspended (time served), and granted admission into CODC with 3 years of probation.
Commonwealth of PA v. "SM"
23-year-old client facing charges that included drug delivery resulting in death.
Our client was incarcerated for approx. 2 years awaiting sentencing. Facing a sentence of 20-40 years. The attorney shared how impactful our mitigation efforts (report, extensive discovery review, and a video) were in leveraging to get the ADA on board for immediate release on parole.
State of Maine v. "JW"
20-year-old client faced attempted murder, elevated aggravated assault, and other related lesser charges. An agreement was made to dismiss the attempted murder for a sentence of 20 years with all but between 2 and 10 suspended. A mitigation report was provided for sentencing. Client was sentenced to 20 years with all but 4.5 years suspended.
State of Maine v. "AM"
23-year-old client facing charges of manslaughter and drug trafficking. A mitigation memorandum was provided for sentencing which was instrumental in achieving a sentence of 10 years all but 4 suspended. The judge referenced the mitigation memorandum during sentencing.
State of Maine v. "CA"
51-year-old client facing charges of drug trafficking (B). A mitigation memorandum was provided for an open plea sentencing. The client was sentenced to 5 Years, All But 7 Days Suspended, With 3 Years Probation.
State of Maine v. "IN"
21-year-old client facing attempted murder, agg assault, robbery, and other lesser charges. A mitigation memorandum was provided and a plea offer was accepted for the robbery charge. The client was sentenced to 10 years all but 400 days suspended (time served), and 4 years of probation.
Commonwealth of PA v. "LP"
24-year-old client facing charges that included homicide by vehicle and involuntary manslaughter. Our client was facing up to 10 years of incarceration. A mitigation report and sentencing preparation were provided. "LP" was sentenced to 7 years of probation with no period of incarceration and maintained driving privileges.
Commonwealth of PA v. "AR"
34-year-old client with charges of possession of firearms with manufactured number altered, terroristic threats, and eluding an officer. Client served approx. 1 year awaiting sentencing. A mitigation report was provided and the client was ordered to time served with 3 years of probation.
State of Maine v. "MA"
20-year-old client facing multiple charges including aggravated assault, criminal OUI, driving to endanger, allowing minors to possess alcohol. Mitigation was utilized at the settlement conference and was contributory in receiving a favorable offer from the prosecutor.
Commonwealth of PA v. "JW"
Client pleaded guilty to (2 counts) unlawful contact with a minor; involuntary deviate sexual intercourse with a child; and possession with the intent to deliver.
The client was sentenced as follows:
IDSI w/child 4-10 years with 3 years of probation, 1 year of probation consecutive to confinement for Unlawful Contact with a Minor, and PWID 2 years of probation.
*Attorney references available by request.
Contact Us
Transformational Mitigation, LLC is always accepting new clients.
We believe mitigation services should be available to everyone navigating the legal system at any stage of their case. A package can be tailored to suit your individualized needs. If you have an inquiry please send us a message regarding the case time frame and needs. Every contact is very important to us.
BACK TO TOP